Bunion Pain Under Your Second Toe? It May Not Be a Fracture

By Dr. Kristina Janson, DPM – Walk Healthy, Manhattan

Recently a doctor called our office about a patient whose pain under the second toe was so sharp that she suspected a fracture. We sent the patient straight for an X-ray, and the images came through our portal right away. There was no fracture. It was a very bad bunion. Because her big toe joint was no longer working properly, she was putting nearly all of her weight on her second metatarsal, a small bone that was never meant to carry that load.
That case is a good reminder that bunion pain doesn't always show up at the bump. Here is what's really going on, and what you can do about it.
What is a bunion?
A bunion forms when the big toe starts drifting toward the little toes. As it drifts, it pushes the long bones of the foot (the metatarsals) apart. The bump people see on the side of the foot is the head of the first metatarsal sticking out.

Shoes play a part. About 95% of bunion surgery is done on women, which points to the pressure of narrow, pointed and high-heeled shoes.

Why the pain can be under the second toe
The big toe joint is built to carry your weight. The first metatarsal is a big, strong bone with two small bones underneath (the sesamoids) to help absorb pressure. When a bunion makes that joint dysfunctional, the weight shifts to the second metatarsal, which is much thinner. The result can be intense pain in the ball of the foot that feels like a stress fracture.

The real cause: pronation
Shoes matter, but most people with bunions also have pronated feet. Pronation means the arch rolls in and collapses when you stand and walk.

When the foot rolls in, the big toe hits the ground first, and the ground pushes the first ray (the whole line of bones on the inside of the foot) upward. The big toe has nowhere to go, so it slips sideways to get out of the way. Over time, that sideways slip becomes a bunion.

Why bunions come back after surgery
My patient told me she didn't want surgery because all her friends had bunion surgery and their bunions came back. That happens because the bunion isn't the primary problem. Pronation is. If the ground keeps shoving the first ray up, the big toe will keep being pushed out of line.
That's why orthotics matter so much. A good orthotic takes pressure off the area under the big toe joint, so the toe has room to rest in line. If you do have bunion surgery, you still need orthotics afterward to treat the cause and keep the correction.
My patient already had very good orthotics, but they were old, and the podiatrist who made them is no longer practicing. We are making her a new pair.
Toe spacers: buy a few and experiment
Many patients with bunions have already discovered toe spacers on their own. A spacer is anything that sits between the big toe and the second toe: foam, red or clear silicone, felt, and many other materials. There are also sleeves that go over the second toe and pads that cover the bunion joint so your shoe doesn't rub it. Doctors call these orthodigital devices.

Patients always ask me which one is best. Honestly, I can't predict it. One patient will swear by a spacer, and the next will tell me it was a waste of money. So my advice is to buy several. They cost about $5 to $20 each, so for around $40 you can try different kinds and find the one you like. You'll find them on Amazon, FootSmart (look in the bunion department) and Dr. Jill's.
Bunion surgery: two approaches
I trained as a bunion surgeon. One year I performed 400 bunion surgeries, so I know the options well. Today there are two main approaches:
Traditional (open) bunion surgery: the surgeon cuts the bone, realigns it and holds it in place with pins, screws or a plate.
Minimally invasive bunion surgery: done through a pinhole-sized incision. The surgeon watches a live imaging screen and uses a small cutting instrument to reshape the bone. It requires special equipment, so fewer surgeons offer it.


I no longer do surgery. Over the years I moved toward something almost nobody does anymore: making custom orthotics entirely by hand. When my patients are thinking about surgery, I examine the foot, give my advice, and suggest they meet two or three surgeons. You don't have to marry your surgeon, but you should like them.
Wear the fancy shoes, but don't walk in them
High heels and narrow shoes contribute to bunions. You can still wear them for an event, a restaurant or the theater. Just don't walk there in them. Wear comfortable, foot-shaped shoes on the way and change at the door. When my husband and I walk around Manhattan, we love spotting people switching their shoes outside. Very smart!
Key takeaways
Pain under the second toe can come from a bunion, not just a fracture. An X-ray tells the difference.
Most bunions are driven by pronation, not only by shoes.
Orthotics treat the cause. Wear them instead of surgery or after surgery to keep the correction.
Try several inexpensive toe spacers to find what works for you.
If you're considering surgery, meet two or three surgeons and pick one you like.
Watch the video
See me demonstrate all of this on a foot skeleton in my YouTube video.
Make an appointment
At Walk Healthy I make custom orthotics by hand in my own office, with no outside lab, and I can adjust them anytime as your feet change. If bunions or ball-of-foot pain are slowing you down, come see me.
Walk Healthy – Dr. Kristina Janson, DPM
185 Madison Avenue, Suite 802, New York, NY 10016
Phone: 212-689-9388
We accept Original Medicare (Part B) and Medigap.
This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for a personal medical evaluation.



Comments